Composite case study

One plan, start to finish

A 160-employee Texas mechanical contractor (composite), followed through the seven steps. Step 0, the public filing read, comes before Step 1 and is optional. It is not an eighth step.

A health plan decision is supposed to look like any other seven-figure purchase: a market check, a written comparison, a file. Most do not, because the renewal letter arrives as a single number from a single carrier through a single broker, and the only alternative on the table is to ask for a smaller number. This document follows one company through the seven steps. Step 0, the public filing read, comes before Step 1 and is optional. It is not an eighth step. The story runs from that public read to the second-year renewal that needed one page.

Who the company is. A 160-employee Texas mechanical contractor (composite): about 270 people on the medical plan, one carrier since the first filing on record, January 1 renewal. A composite built from the 52-company peer set. No real company’s filings or claims are shown; every figure is modeled so the arithmetic holds together. The filing history is modeled in the shape of a Form 5500 Schedule A filed with the U.S. Department of Labor; peer medians are from the 52 filings. No client is identified. Advisory illustration, not legal or tax advice. Its filing history follows patterns common in those filings without copying any one of them.

What is modeled and what is not. Every figure about the company is modeled: the filing history (carrier tenure, employees, lives, premium, broker pay, by year), the census, the renewal letter, the claims, the quotes, the decision and the dates. The filing history is built in the shape of a Form 5500 Schedule A, and everything after it is built from that history and from the 52-company peer set, so that anyone can check the arithmetic. Peer medians are from the 52 filings themselves. Each section says in its first line what it adds. The process, the deliverables, the timing and the pay are as I run them.

The seven steps, with Step 0 before them

StepWhat happensRead
0, before the sevenPublic Form 5500 filing read. Optional beforehand. Not an eighth stepBefore Step 1
1. IntroductionThe conversationIntroduction
2. PaperworkEngagement letter, broker-of-record letter, and written compensation disclosure. Any time of year. 150 days out at the latest for the coming renewalPaperwork
3. OnboardingTransfer takes about a month. Year-round plan servicing starts that dayOnboarding
4. Plan ReportWritten from carrier data once transferred. No quotes and no savings promises. Follows a signed broker-of-record letter and the transfer, usually about a monthPlan Report
5. Renewal strategy and marketFrom 90 days out. Shop fully insured, level-funded, and self-funded options when group size and claims fit. Compensation disclosed in writing before the plan goes through on every optionRenewal strategy
6. Decision and rolloutThe owner approves. The decision file is documented. Open enrollment is runDecision
7. All year, every yearOngoing servicing. The next cycle starts 150 days before renewalAll year

What an employer should take from it

  • In this model, the renewal moved $140,000 the day the group went to market, and nothing about the group had changed.
  • The structure that won had a maximum annual cost below the current year, and it had never been offered.
  • Pay is carrier commission. Every dollar paid on the contract is disclosed in writing before the plan goes through, for the current plan and every option quoted, in dollars and per employee. The filing shows the incumbent’s pay on the renewal as issued would have been about $118,000.
  • The second year needed one page. That is the point: the first year does the heavy lifting, and after that the file does.

Every page ends with the paragraph the owner used to tell the partners. If you can retell a decision in five sentences, you understood it; if you cannot, ask more questions before you accept.

Want this run on your plan?

The first step asks for nothing: send me the company name and I will read your public filing the way step 0 reads this one. It uses only the public record, so no engagement is required. If the numbers say the renewal is worth a look, the next step is switching brokers. Nothing is analyzed or quoted, and none of your documents or claims are used, until the engagement letter is approved and the broker-of-record letter is signed.

Step 0, before the seven steps: the public filing

This is optional beforehand. It is not an eighth step.

This step shows the filing history in the shape of a Form 5500 Schedule A: employees, covered lives, premium and broker pay, by year, and the date the read was sent.

The company is a Texas mechanical contractor with about 160 employees. It has filed a Form 5500 with a medical Schedule A every year since the 2021 plan year. This is the whole of what the filing shows, and it is what the owner received by mail on July 21, 2025, 164 days before the January 1 renewal, with no request attached.

Plan yearEmployees on planCovered livesMedical premiumPremium per lifeBroker pay% of premium
2021about 130about 230$1.05M$4,565$60,9005.8%
2022about 145about 250$1.32M$5,280$73,9205.6%
2023about 160about 270$1.66M$6,148$89,6405.4%

Three things an owner can see without asking anyone:

  1. Since 2021 the group has grown about 23% (about 130 to 160 employees) and its covered lives about 17% (about 230 to 270), but the premium grew about 58%. Per covered person the plan went from $4,565 to $6,148, up about 35% in two years, roughly 16% a year. Per employee it now runs about 70% above the peer median (about $10,375 against $6,094). The mix got lighter, from about 1.77 covered lives per employee to about 1.69, so growth explains less than half of the increase. Price explains the rest.
  2. One carrier, one broker, every filing. The group is now a different risk than it was at about 130 employees, and it has never been priced by anyone but the incumbent.
  3. Broker pay edged down as a share of premium, from 5.8% to 5.4%, but rose about 47% in dollars, from $60,900 to $89,640, because it is a percentage of a premium that grew about 58%. Nobody decided to pay the broker $89,640 a year; it happened.

What the filing cannot show: the renewal letter, the claims, who is on which tier, what employees pay, or whether the broker has ever put the group to market. Every one of those is a document the owner already has or is entitled to.

What the owner told the partners

Our health plan filing is public and I read it. We paid about $1.66 million in 2023 to one carrier we have never priced against anyone else, and the broker’s pay has risen almost half in two years with the premium without anyone deciding that. I want to find out what the renewal looks like against the market before we accept it. Looking does not require an engagement.

Step 1: Introduction, and Step 2: Paperwork

New in this step: the dates and the conversation.

The owner called on July 28, a week after the public filing read arrived. Forty minutes; the company’s controller sat in. No quotes were discussed, because there was nothing to quote from. Two questions came up that the public record had already answered (who is the broker, what are they paid) and one it had not: what the renewal would say. It had not arrived yet, and would not until about 90 days out.

Three documents were completed by the owner, as plan sponsor, on August 4, 150 days before the renewal, before any work on the company’s documents began:

  1. Engagement letter. Scope and the two deliverables, the Plan Report and the renewal strategy. Both are included, paid through the plan as placement commission, not billed to the company. Any special project would be priced here, before approval, never added later.
  2. Broker-of-record letter. Moves the agent of record on the existing contract with the incumbent carrier. This is what lets me pull the carrier’s experience reports and the renewal workbook. The carrier does not change the commission schedule or the premium until renewal, so for September through December the commission already built into the contract, the incumbent’s 5.4%, was paid to me instead: about $35,200 for the four months, stated in dollars on the disclosure the owner approved. Nothing about the company’s cost changed; the same money went to a different broker. From the January 1 renewal, pay is carrier commission, often set in the rates the carrier files with the state. Every dollar paid on the contract is disclosed in writing before the plan goes through.
  3. Compensation disclosure. Every dollar paid on the contract is disclosed in writing before the plan goes through, for the current plan and every option quoted, in dollars and per employee. Pay is carrier commission, often set in the rates the carrier files with the state. For comparison, the filing shows the incumbent was paid $89,640 on the 2023 premium, and 5.4% of the renewal as issued, which arrived in October, would have been about $118,000.

Who sends what. The company sent only a payroll roster (no Social Security numbers), the last payroll deduction report, the contribution split, and who to work with. Everything else came from the carrier, because I was now the broker of record: the plan documents, rates, invoices, enrollment list, claims (up to 24 months) and the renewal. The broker of record transferred on September 3, about a month after the letters went through. From then I serviced the plan: adds and terms, ID cards, billing, employee questions.

164 days from the first envelope to the new plan year

Dated steps for a January 1, 2026 renewal. The order is always the same: paperwork, then documents, then the Plan Report, then the market, then the decision. The dates are modeled.

DateDayWhat happened
Jul 21, 20250Public filing read sent
Jul 287First call with the owner
Aug 414Engagement letter approved, BOR signed, comp disclosure approved (150 days before renewal)
Sep 344Broker of record transfers; servicing starts
Sep 1758Carrier data in: plan documents, enrollment, 24 months of claims
Oct 172Plan Report
Oct 374Renewal in hand (+11.8% medical)
Oct 1889Open enrollment dates locked
Oct 2798Firm quotes in
Nov 2104Enrollment dates announced to employees
Nov 3105Renewal strategy delivered
Nov 6108Decision file approved
Nov 17 to Dec 2119 to 134Open enrollment
Jan 1, 2026164New plan year

Nothing is priced until August 4, when the paperwork is approved.

Why paperwork comes first: Nothing is analyzed or quoted, and none of your documents or claims are used, until the engagement letter is approved and the broker-of-record letter is signed. Once a broker has quoted, the quote is the pitch and the paperwork is the close. In this order, the owner knows what I am paid before I know what the market says, and the decision file starts on day one.

What the owner told the partners

I approved an engagement letter, signed a broker-of-record letter that moves our existing policy to a new broker, and approved a disclosure of his pay in dollars. Nothing about our coverage has changed. Neither deliverable is billed to us. Pay is carrier commission. Between the broker-of-record transfer and the next renewal, the existing commission schedule already in the carrier contract applies, and our premium does not change. Every dollar on the current contract and every renewal option quoted is disclosed in writing before the plan goes through.

Step 3: Onboarding

New in this step: the census, the renewal letter, the contribution schedule and the claims report.

The company’s part arrived within a week of the paperwork, because every item already existed. The carrier’s part followed the broker-of-record transfer: plan documents, enrollment and 24 months of claims on September 17, and the renewal on October 3. Names came off the census; no Social Security numbers were sent.

DocumentWhat it showedSent byDays to receive
Census160 employees, 270 lives, average age 38.4, 71% male, 86% of home ZIPs within 40 miles of the shopBuilt from the company’s payroll roster (no Social Security numbers) and the carrier’s enrollment list2 for the roster; enrollment September 17
Plan summariesOne PPO with the incumbent carrier, $2,500 deductible, $5,000 out-of-pocket; dental and vision bundledThe carrierSeptember 17, 14 days after the transfer
Renewal letter, January 1, 2026+11.8% on medical; +4% dental, flat visionThe carrierArrived October 3, 90 days out
Contributions by tierEmployees pay 20% of employee-only and 50% of the dependent incrementThe company: the contribution split and the last payroll deduction report3
Broker compensation disclosureNone on file. The owner had never received onen/an/a
Carrier experience report24 months of paid claims by month, large claimants over $50,000, requested under the BORThe carrierSeptember 17, 14 days after the transfer

26 family contracts carry 30% of the premium

Annual premium by coverage tier at 2025 rates, 160 employees, 270 covered lives. Census and rates modeled.

TierEmployeesCovered livesMonthly rateAnnual premiumShare
Employee only9494$650$733K38%
Employee + spouse2244$1,365$360K18%
Employee + child(ren)1842$1,230$266K14%
Family2690$1,905$594K30%

Total $1.95M a year, $1,018 per employee per month. Employees pay 20% of employee-only and 50% of the dependent increment.

Two things stood out before any analysis. The family tier is 26 contracts, 16% of employees, and 30% of the premium, so the family contribution is where the largest employee decisions live. And the plan had never received a written broker compensation disclosure, which the law has required since the 2022 renewal.

What the owner told the partners

We sent only a payroll roster, our last payroll deduction report, the contribution split and who to work with. The carrier sent everything else once the broker change was in, including a claims report. We had never been given the broker’s compensation in writing, which we were supposed to get every year since 2022. That is now fixed going forward.

Step 4: the Plan Report

New in this step: the claims figures.

Delivered October 1, before the renewal arrived. The Plan Report follows a signed broker-of-record letter and the transfer, usually about a month. It is written from carrier data once the plan is transferred: what the plan costs per employee, who is on it, how it is funded, what the claims show, what is out of line against public benchmarks, and the strategy for the renewal. No quotes and no savings promises.

What it found.

  • The group’s own claims, net of two large claimants, rose 3.1% in a year. For context, among the 22 peer companies with filings back to 2019, median premium is up about 30% over that whole period.
  • The 24-month loss ratio was 79% in 2024 and 67% in 2025. Two claimants, $312,000 and $168,000, account for the difference between this group and an ordinary one. Both are above the $125,000 pooling point, which means the carrier’s own underwriting formula is supposed to spread them, not charge them back in full.
  • The group has about 270 lives. That is large enough for a level-funded contract from three carriers and for self-funding with stop-loss. It has never been offered either.

The strategy for the renewal. When the renewal lands, go to market with fully insured, level-funded and self-funded options, because at about 270 lives the self-funded structure belongs in the comparison, and because the group has never been priced by anyone else and has structures available to it that return the claims data permanently.

Sometimes the renewal is at or under trend and the claims support it. The market is still shopped, because it is shopped whether the renewal is high or in line, and the decision file records that the plan was checked.

What the owner told the partners

The Plan Report is in. Our own claims, apart from two large ones the carrier is supposed to pool, grew about 3%. We have never been quoted by another carrier or shown a level-funded option, and at our size we qualify for both. When the renewal lands, the plan goes to market, firm quotes in 20 to 25 days, and none of it is billed to us. If the renewal is fair, we accept it knowing that.

Step 5: the renewal strategy and market, firm quotes in 20 to 25 days

New in this step: the renewal letter, every quote, the claims and the carrier responses.

The renewal, against what the Plan Report expected

The renewal arrived October 3, 90 days out.

The renewal asked for 11.8%. Nothing underneath it moved that fast.

Year-over-year increase. Renewal letter and claims are modeled.

MeasureIncrease
Renewal as issued11.8%
Carrier trend quoted for 20268.5%
This group’s own claims trend3.1%

Claims trend: 2025 paid claims per employee per month against 2024, net of claims above the pooling point.

  • The renewal asked for 11.8%. Carrier trend quoted for 2026 ran about 8.5%. The group’s own claims, net of two large claimants, rose 3.1%, as the Plan Report showed.
  • The renewal is not outrageous: it is within what carriers ask of a group with two large claims. The plan went to market as the Plan Report set out.

The renewal strategy

Delivered November 3. Three structures priced side by side, each with what the broker is paid written next to it, plus the claims analysis and the renewal rebuilt from the carrier’s own workbook.

Who was asked, and who answered

MarketStructureResponse
Carrier BFully insured and level-fundedQuoted both
Carrier CFully insured and level-fundedQuoted both
Carrier DFully insuredDeclined, under its preferred size for the region
Incumbent carrierFully insured renewalRevised from +11.8% to +4.6% after being told the group was in the market
Stop-loss market via wholesalerSelf-funded, $100,000 specificTwo carriers quoted

Two carriers write most of the 52 peer groups, and both were in this comparison. The point of asking a third carrier and the stop-loss market is that it keeps the first two honest.

How the quotes landed

How the 2026 quotes landed: renewal as issued, then the market

Annual medical cost for 160 employees, with broker pay in each option. Modeled from the group’s 2025 premium and 2025 market relativities for Texas groups of this size. The incumbent’s pay on the last filing is 5.4%. On every option I quote, pay is carrier commission, and every dollar is disclosed in writing before the plan goes through, in dollars and per employee. The table does not print a fixed fee for that commission.

OptionAnnual medical costBroker pay
Current 2025$1.95M$105K
Incumbent renewal as issued$2.18M$118K
Incumbent revised after market$2.04MDisclosed in writing
Carrier B fully insured$2.00MDisclosed in writing
Carrier C fully insured$2.08MDisclosed in writing
Carrier Ddeclined to quote
Carrier B level-funded, max (chosen)$1.93MDisclosed in writing
Carrier C level-funded, max$1.97MDisclosed in writing
Self-funded, max liability$2.05MDisclosed in writing

Level-funded options shown at maximum annual cost.

Three things to read off that chart:

  1. The renewal moved $140,000 the day the group went to market. Nothing about the group changed between October 3, when the renewal arrived, and October 27, when the firm quotes were in. What changed is that the incumbent knew it was being compared, so the first number was not a market price.
  2. The level-funded maximum came in under the current year. Carrier B’s maximum annual cost, the most the group can pay if claims run badly, was $1.93 million against $1.95 million current and $2.18 million renewal as issued. If claims run as they did in 2025 net of the two large claimants, the group gets a share of the surplus back and, for the first time, keeps its own claims data.
  3. Broker pay is disclosed on every option I quote. Every dollar paid on the contract is disclosed in writing before the plan goes through, in dollars and per employee. The filing shows the incumbent’s pay on the renewal as issued would have been about $118,000.

What the claims said

Two claimants, not the whole group, drove the 2024 loss ratio

Paid medical claims by month against monthly premium. Carrier experience report, 24 months, modeled. Pooling point $125,000.

MonthPaid claimsPremiumNote
Jan to Jun 2024$78K to $110K a month$148.3K a month
Jul 2024$358K$148.3Kone $312K claimant
Aug to Dec 2024$79K to $134K a month$148.3K a month2024 claims: 79% of premium
Jan to Apr 2025$84K to $101K a month$162.8K a month
May 2025$284K$162.8Kone $168K claimant
Jun to Dec 2025$81K to $99K a month$162.8K a monthOct to Dec projected; 2025 claims: 67% of premium

Net of the two claimants above the $125K pooling point, claims ran 66% of premium over 24 months.

Net of the two claimants above the pooling point, the group ran a 66% loss ratio over 24 months. A group running that loss ratio is a candidate to keep its own good years rather than leave them with a fully insured carrier. It is also the single fact that the fully insured renewal letter did not mention.

What the owner told the partners

Four carriers and the stop-loss market were asked. Three carriers quoted, and two stop-loss carriers priced a self-funded option. Our current carrier dropped its renewal from 11.8% to 4.6% once it knew we were shopping. Another carrier offered a level-funded plan where the most we can pay next year is less than we pay now, we get money back if claims are good, and we own our claims data. Every quote shows the broker’s pay next to it, disclosed in writing before the plan goes through. I have a recommendation and the file behind it.

Step 6: Decision and rollout

New in this step: the decision and the figures in it.

Approved November 6 by the owner as plan administrator. The file is six pages and this is its first.

Decision

Move the medical plan to Carrier B on a level-funded contract effective January 1, 2026. Keep the plan design (deductible, out-of-pocket, network tier) within 5% of current so employees see a carrier change, not a benefit cut. Keep dental and vision with the incumbent for one more year; they renewed at 4% and flat and were not the problem.

Why this and not the others

OptionAnnual costBroker payWhy not
Incumbent renewal as issued$2,184,000~$118,00011.8% against a 3.1% claims trend; no market check
Incumbent revised$2,044,000Disclosed in writingStill above current; fully insured keeps the surplus and the data
Carrier B fully insured$1,995,000Disclosed in writingLower than the incumbent, but same structure: good years go to the carrier
Carrier C fully insured$2,079,000Disclosed in writingNot competitive
Carrier B level-funded$1,930,000 maximum; about $1,760,000 expectedDisclosed in writingChosen
Carrier C level-funded$1,970,000 maximumDisclosed in writingHigher maximum, smaller surplus share
Self-funded, stop-loss$2,050,000 maximum; about $1,700,000 expectedDisclosed in writingLowest expected cost, but the owner wanted one year of owned claims data before taking on a maximum above the current premium

What it cost employees

Twenty-three employees had a provider outside the new network; three had ongoing treatment and were moved under transition-of-care. Contribution percentages were unchanged; because the composite rate went down, the family contribution fell about $9 a month.

What is in the file

The Plan Report, the renewal strategy, all six market quotes as received (fully insured and level-funded from Carrier B and Carrier C, and two stop-loss quotes), the carrier’s revised renewal letter, the compensation disclosure, the census summary without names, the claims report, and this page. The next person to ask “how was this decided” gets the file, not a recollection.

The modeled maximum cost for 2026 is $254,000 below the renewal as issued. That figure is in the file because it is what the decision was measured against, not because it was promised in advance. Nobody quoted a savings number to this owner before the paperwork was approved.

What the owner told the partners

We are moving medical to a new carrier on a level-funded plan January 1. Worst case we pay $1.93 million, which is less than this year and $254,000 less than the renewal we were handed. If claims run as they have, we get a share back. Twenty-three people had to check their doctors and three had care transferred. Dental and vision stay put. Everything that went into this is in one file with my approval on it, and the broker’s fee is on page two.

Step 7: All year, every year

New in this step: the 2026 claims and the 2027 renewal.

Servicing never stopped between renewals. The next cycle started 150 days before January 1, 2027, with the claims review at 120 days and the renewal in hand at about 90. This time the documents included something the group had never had: nine months of its own claims, on a contract it controls.

What the year showed

  • Paid claims through September ran 68% of the maximum funding level. One claimant exceeded the specific stop-loss; the carrier absorbed it, which is what the stop-loss is for.
  • Projected surplus at year end: $84,000, of which the contract returns 50%, so about $42,000 is expected back to the plan once the year closes.
  • Carrier B’s 2027 renewal on the level-funded contract: +3.9%, against a quoted trend of about 7.5%.

The renewal strategy, second year

Verdict: accept the renewal. The renewal is under trend, the claims support it, the market was shopped and nothing beat it, and the commission disclosed in writing before the plan goes through is unchanged. One page went in the decision file: renewal reviewed, market shopped, approved.

That is the ordinary outcome, and it should be. The point of year one was not the $254,000. It was that every year after it starts from a file instead of a letter.

The standing calendar

Days before renewalStep
All yearServicing: adds and terms, ID cards, billing, employee questions
150Next cycle starts
120Claims review
90Renewal in hand, compared with what the Plan Report expected; market shopped, firm quotes in 20 to 25 days
75Open enrollment dates locked
60Enrollment dates announced
About 60 to 55Renewal strategy delivered; decision file approved
45 to 30Open enrollment
0New plan year

What the owner told the partners

Year one of the level-funded plan: claims are running 68% of the maximum, we expect about $42,000 back, and the renewal is 3.9%. The renewal strategy says accept it, so we are accepting it. Same broker, same disclosed commission, one page added to the file. The market was shopped and nothing beat it, and it will be shopped again next year whether the renewal is high or in line.

A composite built from the 52-company peer set. No real company’s filings or claims are shown; every figure is modeled so the arithmetic holds together. The filing history is modeled in the shape of a Form 5500 Schedule A filed with the U.S. Department of Labor; peer medians are from the 52 filings. No client is identified. Advisory illustration, not legal or tax advice.

Start where this company started.

The Plan Report is step 4. It follows a signed broker-of-record letter and the transfer, usually about a month. It is written from carrier data once the plan is transferred, with no quotes and no savings promises. Pay is carrier commission, disclosed in writing before the plan goes through.

Questions first? Email aloha@mattragudo.com or book a 30 minute call.