How the process works
Defensible health plan decisions
A record that holds up if anyone questions the decision. Seven steps, each with a written record. Step 0, a public filing read, is optional beforehand and is not an eighth step.
Short answer. A defensible health plan decision leaves a written file: what was checked, what options were priced, what it costs, and who decided. The work is seven steps. Step 0, a public filing read or the self-run Renewal Benchmark Check, is optional beforehand and is not an eighth step.
What “defensible” means
A health plan decision should be one your company can defend: not just what was chosen, but how.
- It supports fiduciary duties. A prudent process, reasonable fees, and acting in participants’ interest.
- It supports disclosure requirements. Knowing what is paid, to whom, and why.
The seven steps
Step 0 is optional beforehand: a public Form 5500 filing read, or the self-run Renewal Benchmark Check. It is not an eighth step.
| Step | Who | What happens |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Introduction | You and me | We talk through the renewal and whether to go further |
| 2. Paperwork | You | Engagement letter, broker-of-record letter, and written compensation disclosure. Any time of year. 150 days out at the latest for the coming renewal |
| 3. Onboarding | Me | The transfer takes about a month. Year-round plan servicing starts that day |
| 4. Plan Report | Me | Written from carrier data once the plan is transferred. No quotes and no savings promises. It follows a signed broker-of-record letter and the transfer, usually about a month |
| 5. Renewal strategy and market | Me | From 90 days out. Fully insured, level-funded, and self-funded are shopped when group size and claims fit. Compensation is disclosed in writing before the plan goes through on every option |
| 6. Decision and rollout | You | You approve. The decision file is documented. Open enrollment is run |
| 7. All year, every year | Me | Ongoing servicing. The next cycle starts 150 days before renewal |
Step 1: Introduction
This is the conversation. Nothing is analyzed from your documents yet. If you want a public read first, that is Step 0, and it stays optional.
Step 2: Paperwork
Paperwork comes first. Nothing is analyzed or quoted, and none of your documents or claims are used, until the engagement letter is approved and the broker-of-record letter is signed. Switching does not add a separate engagement fee: your current broker's commission is already built into your rates, and the broker-of-record letter moves it to me.
What I need from you: a payroll roster (no Social Security numbers), the last payroll deduction report, the contribution split, and who to work with. That is all. Once I am broker of record, the carrier sends the rest: plan documents, rates, invoices, the enrollment list, up to 24 months of claims, and the renewal when it is released. A business associate agreement is in place before any claims detail on individuals comes in.
I confirm: the decision deadline, and who holds decision authority, so nothing stalls later.
What it costs: onboarding, servicing, the Plan Report and the renewal strategy are included. Pay is carrier commission, often set in the rates the carrier files with the state, and it is not billed to you. Between the broker-of-record transfer and the next renewal, the existing commission schedule already in the carrier contract applies, and the employer’s premium does not change. Every dollar on the current contract and every renewal option quoted is disclosed in writing before the plan goes through, in dollars and per employee. Self-funded is a standard option shopped every renewal, alongside fully insured and level-funded, when group size and claims fit. Running or building a custom self-funded structure once it is chosen, or a special project outside standard broker placement and servicing, is priced separately in the engagement letter before work starts. How I’m paid.
Step 3: Onboarding
The transfer takes about a month. Year-round plan servicing starts that day: adds and terms, ID cards, billing, and employee questions.
Step 4: Plan Report
The Plan Report follows a signed broker-of-record letter and the transfer, usually about a month. It is written from carrier data once the plan is transferred. No quotes and no savings promises.
What the Plan Report takes apart
The renewal number alone says nothing. I take it apart.
- Renewal analysis. The increase split into its five drivers: trend, experience, demographics, plan design and fees.
- Medical cost analysis. High-cost claims, site-of-care patterns and price variation.
- Pharmacy cost analysis. Specialty share, generic use, and contract terms: spread, rebates, rights to inspect claims data.
- Fee review. Every party the plan pays, and on what basis.
Everything I find goes into a documented findings log.
Benchmarks inside the Plan Report
| Source | Use |
|---|---|
| Peer plan filings (Form 5500) | By size, funding type and industry |
| State-level data files | Local market context |
| AHRQ employer survey (MEPS-IC) | Employer cost by firm size band |
| Medicare-based pricing | A neutral yardstick for medical costs |
| Transparent pharmacy pricing | A yardstick for drug costs |
The output shows where your plan sits against its peer band on cost per employee, contribution split and deductible. I benchmark market pricing. When a fee reasonableness opinion is needed, it comes from an independent firm. See the Health Plan Visibility Studies for what the public filings alone can show.
Step 5: Renewal strategy and market
From about 90 days out, fully insured, level-funded, and self-funded are shopped every renewal when group size and claims fit. Every dollar paid on each option is disclosed in writing before the plan goes through. Running or building a custom self-funded structure once it is chosen is priced separately in the engagement letter before that work starts.
I market each path across carriers and administrators, then model cost, risk and employee impact.
| Funding path | Who carries claims risk | How cost behaves |
|---|---|---|
| Fully insured | The insurer | Fixed premium, reset at renewal |
| Level-funded | The employer, up to a cap | Fixed monthly payments, settled after the plan year |
| Self-funded | The employer | Moves with actual claims |
Plan design and contribution scenarios run against each path. Where stop-loss is in play, the contract terms matter as much as the price: specific versus aggregate coverage, attachment points, lasering, renewal protections, and the cash you need on hand. More on the trade-offs: level funded vs fully insured.
Two reimbursement arrangements are options too, with the trade-offs in writing. An ICHRA (individual coverage health reimbursement arrangement) gives employees a set, tax-free allowance toward an individual policy they choose, and is available at any company size. A QSEHRA (qualified small employer health reimbursement arrangement) works the same way but is only for employers with fewer than 50 full-time equivalents, and only when the company offers no group plan.
Step 6: Decision and rollout
The owner approves. The decision file is documented. Open enrollment is run.
Two deliverables.
The owner-ready summary: the recommendation, the reasons for it, and the alternatives considered. Short enough to read in one sitting, and built so whoever owns the decision can present it directly.
The decision file: the sources and benchmarks used, the assumptions and risks noted, the fee and disclosure review, and a dated decision trail of who decided what. That file is what holds up later. See one built end to end in One plan, start to finish.
Step 7: All year, every year
Servicing continues between renewals. The next cycle starts 150 days before renewal.
Who does what
| You (the owner) | Me | You receive |
|---|---|---|
| Approve the engagement letter and sign the broker-of-record letter | Runs the analysis and handles vendor follow-up | A clear decision |
| Make the decision | Builds the documentation | Budget impact by option |
| Announce enrollment to your employees | Coordinates ACA reporting and plan documents | A record that holds up |
Built for 50 to 500 employees. ACA large-employer rules start at 50 full-time equivalents, and part-time hours count, so groups near 50 should plan before they cross.
Advisory analysis, not legal or tax advice.
Questions people ask
What does "defensible" mean here?
A decision your company can explain later: not only what was chosen, but how. It supports fiduciary duties and disclosure requirements with a dated file.
When do the seven steps start?
Step 1 is the introduction. Step 0, a public Form 5500 filing read or the self-run Renewal Benchmark Check, can happen before that and is not an eighth step. The Plan Report is step 4. It follows a signed broker-of-record letter and the transfer, usually about a month. The renewal strategy and market start from about 90 days out.
What do you need from the employer?
A payroll roster without Social Security numbers, the last payroll deduction report, the contribution split, and who to work with. The carrier sends the rest once the broker-of-record letter goes through.
How are you paid for this process?
Onboarding, servicing, the Plan Report and the renewal strategy are included. Pay is carrier commission, often set in the rates the carrier files with the state, and it is not billed to you. Between the broker-of-record transfer and the next renewal, the existing commission schedule already in the carrier contract applies, and the employer’s premium does not change. Every dollar on the current contract and every renewal option quoted is disclosed in writing before the plan goes through, in dollars and per employee. Self-funded is a standard option shopped every renewal, alongside fully insured and level-funded, when group size and claims fit. Running or building a custom self-funded structure once it is chosen is priced separately in the engagement letter before work starts. See How I’m paid.
What ends up in the decision file?
The summary the owner can retell, the options priced, the compensation disclosure, and the dated decision. It is the record that holds up if anyone asks how the choice was made.
I built and sold a health insurance agency: grew it to 60 agents in about 3 years, then sold it. Licensed insurance agent since 2014: Texas license 2501238, NPN 17369817.
Start with one upcoming renewal.
Your next renewal is the place to start. You can approve the engagement letter and sign the broker-of-record letter any time of year; for your coming renewal, 150 days before renewal is the latest. The Plan Report follows a signed broker-of-record letter and the transfer, usually about a month.
Questions first? Email aloha@mattragudo.com or book a 30 minute call.